city of san jose council meeting
Vice Mayor Chappie Jones and Councilmembers David Cohen, Dev Davis and Raul Peralez voted in favor of the plan, while Councilmember Sylvia Arenas opposed. So, I guess that kind of shoots down your argument. Disenfranchised voters in D8 and D10. Actions Related to the Surplus and Property Sale and Property Management Agreement for the SureStay Hotel by Best Western Located at 1488 North First Street. Returned Tuesday evening for a regularly scheduled meeting? 2. Last Modified Date: 11/27/2006. This is the first time I have received an email DURING A MEETING from an elected official telling me to call in and support their position. Now, he defends appointments that COMPLETELY ignore the voters and will determine who will serve the outstanding TWO YEARS of a four year term. They are all tyrants. 2022 Byrne Discretionary Community Project Grant Program for the Mobile Crisis Assessment Team. SJS didnt tell us the ratio of pro-election to pro-appointment speakers; but Id bet the pro-election speakers outnumbered the pro-appointment speakers by at least 2-1. The San Jose City Council decided in a special meeting lasting over six hours that it will fill two empty city council seats and not have a special election. 1) Use the eComment tab located on the City Council Agenda page. Stephanie Magallon reports. Is this enough to sway a councilmembers vote and move forward with a special election? As limited as the powers of mayor in San Jose are, they have ways of making friends among councilmembers. | All donations are tax-deductible. If there is a recall, it will consume all the time and resources of the city. She needs to be reprimanded. endobj (Davis). The vast majority not attending could care less and dont want to waste time and money on an elections that change nothing. Your email address will not be published. Use a current, up-to-date browser: Chrome 30+, Firefox 27+, Microsoft Edge 12+, Safari 7+. She is worthless . Ever since the 49ers low-balled San Jose in their suittwo Quater Backs are out with injuries. (Esparza), Presentation of a proclamation declaring October 2022 as National Disability Employment Awareness Month to celebrate the past and present contributions of Americas workers with disabilities and showcase supportive, inclusive employment policies and practices. <> Comments received will be included as a part of the meeting record but will not be read aloud during the meeting. Believe the opposite of what Sergio Jimenez sayslying and deception are his superpowers. Take the jab (repeatedly) or become a second-class citizen. document.getElementById( "ak_js_4" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); San Jos residents deserve a trusted source for unbiased, independent political news. I dont think thats appropriate. Dev Davis There are people who are clamoring for ways to help change this city, but they cant because our city council wants to just do whatever is best for business. 3) https://www.youtube.com/CityofSanJoseCalifornia. It was last amended at election November 8, 1994, which means generations of democratically-elected officials appear to have found no issue with it, including as far as Im aware every council member who took part in the vote tonight. And for all of the people who said a strong mayor system is a power grab then agreed with appointing unelected officials to an already struggling City Council is just hypocrisy at the highest level. You assume just because people dont attend meetings is because they dont care? The exchange between Arenas and Davis also spoke volumes. It makes zero sense. Amendment to the Agreement with SKIData, Inc. for a Parking Access and Revenue Control System for the Norman Y. Mineta San Jos International Airport. Set an example for other workers? I believe you missed the fact that Tony (Clerk) stated that this would not result in one dime coming out of a budget as they have a surplus and funds available. A dedicated public servant, he was known for bringing warmth, compassion, fairness and professionalism in his role as Chair. If a member of the City Council requests discussion on a particular item, that item will be removed from the Land Use Consent Calendar (Item 10.1) and considered separately. Dev Davis continues her bitter tirade because she was a horrible candidate for Mayor and got destroyed in the primary. We can and we should all be more honest, respectful and helpful to each other. The action of the City Council of going forward with appointments for the vacant seats is exemplified by the WP tagline Democracy Dies in Darkness. Adoption of an Ordinance Ratifying Final Expenditures in Various Appropriations for 2021-2022 and Adoption of the Associated Appropriation Ordinance and Funding Sources Resolution amendments in 2021-2022. It makes me wonder. Climate Smart San Jos Plan Semi-Annual Report. He passed away on Friday, May 13, 2022, leaving behind his son, Meehan, and his granddaughter, Ivey. The two appointees will be clones of the seven who voted for appointments. Its not just Mahan. Ironically, the same people that have been screaming from the rooftops to count every vote, suddenly dont want to count any votes and clearly have decided to disenfranchise 200,000 people, many of whom are minorities and women.. Im tired of the citizenry being taken advantage of so people can launch a successful political campaign and immediately begin their climb up the ladder as a professional politician. Numerous residents said they want to cast a ballot in a special electionarguing its their right. That means (there would not) be a representative for District 8 that is going to pipe up and talk about some of those special interests that we have in our community, Arenas said. San Jose will see a stunning shakeup next year with seven new faces on the City Council, with two current elected officials assuming new offices. 80628 and 80659, Councilmembers may be teleconferencing from remote locations. Dennis Hawkins, a District 10 resident, said he supports an appointment because he worries waiting for a special election will leave his district unrepresented. City Initiatives Roadmap - Clean Energy Resilience: Residential Building Electrification Updates and Workforce Development Acceleration Partnership and Master Agreement with BlocPower LLC. Thats a lot of what this is about, Christensen told San Jos Spotlight. Elections change everything? In 2011, the City adopted Envision San Jos 2040, a long-term growth plan that sets forth a vision and a comprehensive road map to guide the City's anticipated growth through the year 2040. . With such a prophesy of doom our only hope is to take the next space ship out. I attended part of the meeting via my phone, part in-person, and part via my laptop. More Power grabbing. How dare you council members take that away! Screen shot from council streaming video. If a member of the City Council requests discussion on a particular item, that item may be removed from the Consent Calendar and considered separately. What a shame. City of San Jose - 2001 Council Meeting Minutes MEETING ARCHIVES 2001 CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES January, 2001 through December, 2001 Minutes of City Council meetings which took place in 2001 are available below in reverse chronological order (the most recent date is at the top of the list and the earliest date is at the bottom). TO BE HEARD AT 9:30 A.M. At one point earlier this year, you couldnt set foot in City Hall without proof of being boosted. Yall are kidding yourselves if you dont think Liccardo & Mahan would be pushing for appointment instead of election if they thought it increased the odds of a pro-business candidate winning. 2) By email to [email protected] by 10:00 a.m. the day of the meeting. Virtual Meeting December 13, 2022 Regular Session 11:00 a.m. How to submit written Public Comment before the City Council Meeting: 1) Use the eComment tab located on the City Council Agenda page. Hes the square peg that portends ill winds for the entrenched politicians and bureaucrats. Voter turnout for special elections is historically low at about 20% to 30%, according to City Clerk Toni Taber. The lack of intelligence in this statement is absurd. Council Agendas *** Send any correspondence related to Council items that you wish Council to see prior to the meeting to [email protected] or Office of the City Clerk, City of San Jos, 200 E Santa Clara Street, San Jos, CA 95113. Exclusive Negotiation Agreements for Affordable Housing Developments on City-Owned Sites. The San Jose City Council meets every Tuesday at 1:30 p.m. I believe that most residents of Willow Glen neighborhoods dont share her twisted value. If you want an appointment maybe the Mayor should be making it vs the entire council that is obviously in labors pocket?? Democracy is not about efficiency. Just another group of disgusting politicians in this country. If a member of the City Council requests discussion on a particular item, that item may be removed from the Consent Calendar and considered separately. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Cheers, boos, middle fingers and the banging of a gavel filled the San Jose City Council chambers on Monday night as officials decided how to fill two vacancies. Theres definitely valid critique to be made of those pushing for appointments vs a special election. I agree, Mahan should have fulfilled his responsibility as a counsel member before seeking higher office. If anything, voters choosing a business backed mayor should be a mandate that they dont want labor CMs, especially in more conservative districts like 8 and 10. Tomorrow, I will be looking to join others who want to take back our city! Of course Labor has already filled out the applications for their preferred candidates. Likewise, the citizens of San Jose can vote to change their city charter if they no longer want their city council to have this option. Care to clarify, and divulge what your position is on the underlying issue? City Initiatives Roadmap - Clean Energy Resilience: Power Procurement Agreements. The San Jose City Council voted 7-4 to appoint two new members to two-year terms to fill District 8 and District 10 vacancies. Had they come into the meeting with their own memo, with facts about cost, timing, a constituent support continuity plan, and ranked choice voting questions answered, it could have gone differently. Mobile Home Park Land Use Designation Status Report. This is a clear break from precedent, Liccardo said just before the midnight vote. We can afford to pay out millions because of the abusive behavior of the San Jose Police Department but we cant afford a special election to determine our representatives? BY YOU HOLDING THEM ACCOUNTABLE IN THE MEDIA IS MEDIA DOINGVITS JOB IS EXACTLY WHAT MEDIA WAS CREATED FOR SUPPORT FOR THE PEOPLE. Amendment to the Administrative Citation Schedule of Fines Resolution. A rather lame take, but this is par for the course from this shill for the big special interest bosses. The question was asked of city staff if we had the funds to do this, and the answer was yes. Not saying the councils decision tonight was good, necessarily, let alone ideal (a lot of people obviously disagree with it). Ive spoken with friends across the country about this subject are theyre stunned that our Council can take away our right to vote and, in dictator fashion, place who they want in place instead. Council Meetings. This isnt like whats going on in presidential elections and alarming amount of people still think the 2020 election was a fraud. Time to move on. Think before you speak. I dont personally know any of the encumbent or wannabe council members. SAN JOSE, Calif. (KGO) -- The San Jose City Council decided in a special meeting lasting over six hours that it will fill two empty city council seats and not have a special. It was Liccardos idea and supported by his lackey Mahan along with all the rest. I cant help but continuing to quote Gandhi: if there is an idiot in power, those who elected him are well-represented., Im embarrassed to be a citizen of this city. New council needs to be held accountable from day 1. I am furious about the council decision. The pro special election side, led by the Mayor, tried to come up with creative last minute live-from-the-dais options. You are out of step with the citizens of our city. Another thing: they need to be called out for their divisive tactics. - RENUMBERED TO ITEM 6.1. City Council Appointment for Vision Zero Task Force. MEETING ARCHIVES. The democrats on the council speak of democracy but voted for authoritarianism. I was online and watched the meeting in its entirety. Mahan countered that there is no price tag for democracy. Because you dont agree with Mahan is good enough reason to demand he relinquish what he won fair and square despite everything thrown at him by Chavez and her sycophantic minions? c. When the Mayor calls for the item on which you wish to speak, click on raise hand. Speakers will be notified shortly before they are called to speak. Keep kissing labors ring, bud, you have no political future after city council so your efforts are fruitless. Items must be received by NOON on the day of the meeting to ensure it can be distributed prior to the meeting. Now Labor will appointment two of their people to the D8 and D10 seats. The people lose because the people elected them, blah blah, blah. Maybe thats the problem you and your ilk have with him he poses a problem for the status quo at 200 E Santa Clara Street. Contact Jana Kadah at [emailprotected] or @Jana_Kadah on Twitter. Agree. Also, I think you should stop talking for others, you dont represent the majority of people living in San Jose, it is just your opinion. Hybrid Meeting - Council Chambers and Virtually -. Sylvia Arenas. We. Just as the Labor Council-members would favor a special election if they thought it benefited them. % Together, we can continue to build a free and independent press that serves Silicon Valley. The Covid lockdown and mandates should have been a clue that we no longer live in a free society. endobj Gail Anne, welcome to the New World Order. Need More Info? There were many valid concerns expressed on both sides of the issue tonight. The police will continue to be handcuffed, morale will sink further, and recruiting will become even more difficult, all while crime rises. Democracy is not alive and well in San Jose, or CA generally. I vote against the communist seven every chance I get, and will spread the word to as many as possible to do the same. No Personal Attack I was very impressed by speakers from the Vietnamese community especially those who came here as refugees escaping the communist regime. She justified her action robbing the right to vote of 200,000 D8 and D10 residents so your district can add a traffic light? Excellent suggestion. 3) https://www.youtube.com/CityofSanJoseCalifornia. The name will be visible online and will be used to notify you that it is your turn to speak. 2) By email to [email protected] by 10:00 a.m. the day of the meeting. Theres no way you believe Matt is any different than the entrenched politicians. Everything is on the table in a power grab. Instead they are being appointed by people who ASSUME what is best for the people. City Council: 12/27/2022: 1:30 PM: Hybrid Meeting CANCELLED: Meeting details: Not available: Not available: Not available: Not available: City Council . What has gotten into San Jose Council? 6 council people not in chambers. City Council Agendas Watch Public Meetings Council Meeting Information City Council Calendar - August 2021 to June 2022 City Council Calendar - August 2022 to June 2023 Guide to Council Meetings Standing Council Committees Agendas Policy for Posting and Processing Written Public Comment For more information please go to the Council Committees page x][o~7B.j{%lYNv-C'%WVrvv&hHvfH7&yt~>$NVb9,VxbT/qAf_p%\8YW,f'(AYZ %'H MfF1%} $9:#ywoCFJmF=6q1U`4EM8nW4+p`. What has Chavez promised Dev Davis? RECALL THE PEOPLE WHO VOTED FOR THIS OR BETTER YET RECALL WHO IS APPOINTED BY COUNCIL. An appointee could come in and the entire district staff could turn over at the same time too. Although the proponents of appointment claim the continuity would benefit their constituents, that remains to be seen. January, 2002 through December, 2002. Enter an email address and name. The same people who vote in special elections are the same who show up at Council meetings with pitchforks, torches and a rope. Before the meeting, dozens of residents rallied with Liccado, Mahan and Councilmember-elect Bien Doan outside City Hall to oppose an appointment process. She said District 8 would be neglected during the budget process if the city waited to elect her successor. Sergio Jimenez Regardless of whether you lean labor or business, people should pick their elected reps. Its called democracy. It is a small amount to pay to protect our democracy. This lineup will make the City of Santa Claras 49er Five look like amateur night. This is a preview of future politics in San Jose with the make up of authoritarian council members. How to observe the Meeting (no public comment): 1) Cable Channel 26, City of San Jos - Meeting of City Council on 10/4/2022 at 1:30 PM Calendar People Add an eComment to a meeting Details Meeting Name: City Council Agenda status: Final Meeting date/time: 10/4/2022 1:30 PM Minutes status: Draft Meeting location: Hybrid Meeting - Council Chambers and Virtually - https://sanjoseca.zoom.us/j/88957084529 Meeting video: No Cursing The Reverend Matthew D. Stanley, Pastor of St. Francis of Assisi Parish. That is what the labor movement is supposed to dothey give a voice to the powerless and empower individuals to unite together. Employees a. I WASNT AWARE THAT WE LIVE IN A DICTATORSHIP. Does that apply to Arenas as well or are you buddies with her? I was at the City Council meeting last night. Bill served on the City of San Joss Civil Service Commission for more than 20 years, most recently serving as the Chair of the Commission. cant hold them accountable in the media, Danny, because the media are just flacks for the democrat elites and techie titans. San Jose Mayor-elect Matt Mahan at the Dec. 5 City Council meeting. 1. Thats your problem, not his. 2) By email to [email protected] by 10:00 a.m. the day of the meeting. A lot of this is driven by Dev Davis because she didnt get to be the prom queen. But as usual, the Councilmembers listened but did not hear the people. Report from the Council Liaison to the Retirement Boards. Alternative phone numbers are: US: +1 (213) 338-8477 or +1 (408) 638-0968 or (877) 853-5257 (Toll Free) Mayor and City Council. Your racism is showing, as you have no idea what a banana republic is or the history of the US in exploiting and exporting violence and dictatorships to South America. Were changing the face of journalism by providing an innovative model for delivering reliable, truthful news to the nations 10th largest city. Term expires 12/31/22 Chief of Staff: J. Reed : DISTRICT 1 Vice Mayor Charles "Chappie" Jones. The same 9 people who thought they were endorsing the future Mayor Chavez in the campaign. Doesnt include the 300+ speakers on zoom. City Home - City Services - About San Jos - Visitors - Feedback - Search. Consider moving to a banana republic like Venezuela if you are experiencing voting fatigue instead of living in an advanced democracy like the U.S.A. where elections change everything. Show up for your job? This is definitely Chavezs first move in the political chess game called the 2024 election. No chance for debates. Is this just the beginning of Chavezs plan to make Mahan a two-year mayor? I cannot believe you fashion yourselves as journalists. To help stop the spread of COVID-19 and keep our community safe, the City of San Jos is currently conducting Boards and Commission meetings virtually and City Council meetings in a hybrid of in-person and virtual using Zoom. Council appointing a member isnt like Newsom appointing Harriss replacement. Wow, as the Washington Post has on its pages Democracy Dies In Darkness.. 1) Use the eComment tab located on the City Council Agenda page. After folks not in favor of the special election , the audience shouted boos and Sam didnt say anything, but maybe once. Find agendas for past and upcoming City Council and Council Committee meetings. Only one person not termed out voted for an election. Yet, we now know that much of what Fauci, the CDC, and the WHO recommended made a bad situation worse, and that cloth and paper masks and social distancing had little effect on transmission. He was supported and endorsed by Mayor Scam Liccardo. Its enough to make people consider holding their nose and supporting instead folks like a returning Liccardo, Guardino, plus maybe some non-profit leaders and of course Staedler, Dillabough, Swensen, and others who have Influence already. Notice to the public: There will be no separate discussion of Land Use Consent Calendar (Item 10.1) as they are considered to be routine by the City Council and will be adopted by one motion. California Strategic Growth Council for the Regional Climate Collaboratives Grant. All Fact-Checkable It will be tens of thousands of people out there paying attention, listening to the candidates, that will force the candidates to go through a long and arduous process of making their case.. 2) Online at: https://sanjoseca.zoom.us/j/88957084529 you are so ideologically possessed you cant see these people are literally feeding you poison and convincing you its kool-aid. document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_3" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); God forbid Labor allows voters decide . If Davis continues on her vengeful path, she needs to be recalled too. Former Councilmember David Pandori accused some lawmakers of supporting an appointment to maintain the labor majority on the council. Harvest Properties is the property owner. Definition of insanity. I saw a beautiful mix of people from all over the world who were begging for the right to vote. I am ashamed for the local DEM rep who said he speaks for 500k registered democrats. It will take a lot for the progressive majorityif there is one in the new yearto resist what the mayor wants to do.. This 7-4 highly political and ideological vote by the city council will have a political backlash that will be more expensive than just a special election. The reason Matt won wasnt just because he actually campaigned, but because Cindys reputation is not a good one. *The previously scheduled Evening Session has been cancelled. What a joke , good luck to those of you who voted for her in the County election . Why is everyone so afraid to spend a little money on a democratic process as opposed to not being afraid of the huge amount of more dollars wasted on failed programs? Adoption of Resolution of Intention to Renew the San Jos Hotel Business Improvement District. City of San Jos - Meeting of City Council on 9/27/2022 at 1:30 PM People Add an eComment to a meeting Details Meeting Name: City Council Agenda status: Final Meeting date/time: 9/27/2022 1:30 PM Minutes status: Draft Meeting location: Hybrid Meeting - Council Chambers and Virtually - https://sanjoseca.zoom.us/j/88957084529 Meeting video: View the master calendar of public meetings. The Mayors behavior was so unprofessional and unbecoming of a Mayor. The national republican party is a disgrace and the local democrats of Santa Clara County have been taken over by labor warriors who think everyone is a racist and people of color are too burdened to vote, so they will do it for them. Accept Labor Negotiations Update. the City of San Jos offers several programs of financial support to ensure a continuing and rich variety of cultural opportunities for its residents as well as visitors to the city. ACCOUNTABLE. Gee, Teri, read what I said. I find this onitselfi disgraceful. Any other Council meeting he lets the audience knows there isnt clapping and cheers, but not this one. Webinar ID is 889 5708 4529. But he has his mind made up. Politicians are all the same: only out for themselves. Her ex-boyfriend Kevin de Leon is getting recalled in LA now, because of the same tactics. But the process was legitimate. I was particularly impressed by the members of the Asian community speaking about what the vote meant to them. Mute all other audio before speaking. We will not be silenced. All Truthfulness. Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team. We dont live in a democracy, its a constitutional republic bud. (Foley), Presentation of a proclamation declaring September 2022 as Ovarian Cancer Awareness Month. One specific thought that no one seemed to mention. but it figures with this group some of the people who did this vote need to resign go to another country ..where they pull this -..! Malcom: shocked as well. But theyll still have the circus in January. I know the current (and forthcoming) council lacks sharp minds, but wow Sergio, just wow. President arent you the same people freebasing Maddow cowering in the corner on how Putin is stealing your democracy? Anyone with a phone, computer, or mobile device could have attended the meeting. Those emails will be attached to the Council Item under Letters from the Public. Please identify the Agenda Item Number in the subject line of your email. Its more like the Senate picking Harris s replacement. Use a current, up-to-date browser: Chrome 30+, Firefox 27+, Microsoft Edge 12+, Safari 7+. Sunnyvale candidate wins election with a single vote, VTA disputes San Joses plan for tiny homes, Perry: Housing lessons from the 2022 elections, California franchise owners fight fast food law. Its nonsensical and these covid policies continue to not prevent people catching a virus that 99%+ of people are safe from and actually prevent good people from getting hired. Its a one-sided state where there is very little political/thought diversity so these seats will be used to appoint more establishment politicians that favor already failed ideas/view-points. Those emails will be attached to the Council Item under "Letters from the Public." Agreement with Destination: Home for Funding from Homeless Housing, Assistance, and Prevention Funding for the Lived Experience Advisory Board of Santa Clara County. Cohen has to do what Labor wants cuz hes up for re-election in 2024. More market rate apartments will be built in and around the moribund and dirty downtown, where everything possible has been done to make driving an automobile more difficult and time consuming, while the bollards proliferate and the double-wide Liccardo bike lanes remain mostly empty most of the time. Talk about a divisive party move. Time to get the appointee recall signatures going.and a test of the dropbox-only voting. Regarding Dev Davisdistrict 6 residents need to think really hard why they voted for hershe is so politically unstableher politics only make sense in bizarro world. Strategically, the pro-appoint Council members issued a memo before the meeting and then each spoke in unity. Here in District 5, we did not expect anything different from our Elected Representative. There will be repercussions. During our NewsMatch campaign, every dollar of your gift is matched (up to $1,000), which helps us bring in-depth, independent news coverage to more communities. Chavezs defeat should be seen for what it was a clear repudiation of labor in this city, despite them pouring millions of dollars trying to get her elected. All the talk across this country about voter fraud & stolen elections but here in San Jose they steal it away in broad daylight. CM Davis laundry list of what her District could do with the money is more than likely correct, but only considering the money was a smokescreen for just not wanting the special election. The world may be watching, as someone stated last night, but we will be the ones bearing the brunt of a poor decision. On the other hand, if theres a special election, voter turnout will be fairly low. This City needs a Strong Mayor system yesterday, and until then, San Jose will be a diminishing laughing stock of a City. Liccardo has faced this choice before, and he voted for a special election, even though pro-business was in the majority. The City Council generally meets every Tuesday at 1:30 p.m. in the City Council Chambers located in City Hall, at 200 East Santa Clara Street. Click *9 to raise a hand to speak. The mor jabs and boosts you get, the weaker your own immune system becomes. Balance your books and take care of the people. WEEK OF DECEMBER 12, 2022 - DECEMBER 16, 2022 CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS December 13, 2022 Closed Session 9:30 a.m. Members of the Public are invited to speak on any item that does not appear on todays Agenda and that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the City Council. 2) https://www.sanjoseca.gov/news-stories/watch-a-meeting, or I am appalled, ashamed, disgusted and disappointed in some members of this council. I guarantee you the overwhelming majority would support an election. Click *9 to raise a hand to speak. Items recommended to be added, dropped, or deferred are usually approved under Orders of the Day unless the Council directs otherwise. Amen, Tim. Remember these names. San Jose hasnt been in balance for a long while. I can list a few things that I believe can be fully funded with that money, said Councilmember Sergio Jimenez. Justice is not about efficiency, it is about fairness, Pandorini said. Its ever so clear that special interests have a stronghold on select members of our council, District 10 resident Deborah Millner said during the meeting. After Labor installs their comrades in D8 and D10, recalls will happen. The City of San Jose awards Operating Grants to a limited number of . Those in favor of appointing new councilmembers criticized the $7 million to $10 million price tag and lengthy timeline for a special election, while those in favor of an election said residents deserve to elect their representatives. The discussion was heated on the dais and during public comment. The UK National Health Service recently reported that now lover half the cases of hospitalization and death are of people who have been vaccinated. Fully opening community centers, enhancing traffic safety to prevent deaths, park maintenance, rebuilding playgroundsthings we get calls about on a daily basis.. Let the people vote. Regardless , Arenas needed to be seen . Has she been on the line regularly with Chavez lately? The name will be visible online and will be used to notify you that it is your turn to speak. At the end of the day, the people lose. Theres clearly a majority for an appointment that would be friendly to (labor) politics. Plata Arroyo Neighborhood Association and Gateway East N.A.C. I care enough to expect we should all be represented and not playing dirty and name calling. Expecting the City Manager to somehow bolster your position with on the spot questions is not a winning strategy. "It is unprecedented and I think it brings shame to our city, " said Mayor Sam Liccardo after the 11:30pm vote. 2002 CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES . But Mahan will get the blame. It seems like every week a new study comes out that says the hundreds of doctors worldwide who signed the GreatBarrington Declaration were correct. And all the talk about voter suppression. - TO BE HEARD AT 4:00 P.M. 2022 California Building Standards Code Adoption. Put that guy in jail. Typical for people that dont like the democratic process to complain about how much elections cost. The South San Jose Police Substation will finally open as a home for community service officers and as a site for training and recruiting. They couldnt get the Mayorship so theyre stealing the 2 council seats. San Jose Retirement Services; Meeting Bodies; People; Upcoming Meetings: Name Meeting Date Meeting Time Meeting Location Meeting Details Agenda Minutes Video eComment; Miscellaneous Agendas . Report of the City Manager, Jennifer Maguire (Verbal Report). As a customer-driven organization, the City of San Jos welcomes any suggestions you might . I dont care for the Republicans, but lately Im beginning to wonder if the Progressives are the new Authoritarian government. Plenty of voter laws have been on the books and later deemed biased and racist. 2) By email to [email protected] by 10:00 a.m. the day of the meeting. Hundreds of residents at City Hall held up let me vote signs and shared impassioned pleas to move forward with a special election to replace District 10 Councilmember Matt Mahan and District 8 Councilmember Sylvia Arenas, who are moving on to new roles as San Jose mayor and Santa Clara County supervisor, respectively. Notice to the public: There will be no separate discussion of Consent Calendar items as they are considered to be routine by the City Council and will be adopted by one motion. How to provide spoken Public Comment during the City Council Meeting: 1) By Phone: (888) 475 4499. In fact, I believe that when you take the oath of office, you should be required to swear to fulfill your full term. (Foley), Presentation of a proclamation declaring October 2022 as National Pedestrian Safety Month to remind drivers to stay alert for pedestrians, cyclists, and other vulnerable road users. But underneath the deliberations over price and principle is politics, political observer Terry Christensen said. Some one explain to me why this would not work better for the citizens. And your saying that they are tired of division. My last point is that I wish people would stop considering the city budget as one large pot of money. If the process is in need of an update, then someone should start drafting the next amendment and put it on the agenda so that this unfortunate situation might be avoided in the future. Status of Open Audit Recommendations as of June 30, 2022. I must be naive because I dont get the pitchfork, torches and rope concept. They have staff send out emails, texts before and during. Presentation of a commendation recognizing John McKay and Michael North for their exemplary community involvement and generous philanthropic endeavors. From partner hotels to the San Jos McEnery Convention Center to the Mineta San Jos International Airport (SJC) - San Jos's visitor industry is collectively putting its best carbon footprint forward. - TO BE HEARD IMMEDIATELY AFTER CONSENT. Blue Ribbon Task Force. This is political. Mr. Jimenez needs to resign if he is too tired of democracy. SAP Center President's Room - 525 W. Santa Clara St. City of Cupertino Community Hall, 10350 Torre Avenue, Cupertino, Clean Energy Community Advisory Commission, Community & Economic Development Committee (CED), Reimagining Public Safety Community Advisory Committee, AD-HOC Committee for Housing Construction & Development Services (inactive). Any dissenting voices from the public will be ignored. The rest saw an opportunity to grab more power on the labor side of the council and found every ridiculous nonsensical argument that they could to support disenfranchising residents. Residents packed into the San Jose City Council chambers to speak for or against holding a special election to fill two vacancies on Dec. 5, 2022. How to submit written Public Comment during the City Council Meeting: 1) Email during the meeting to [email protected], identifying the Agenda Item Number in the email subject line. As of Wednesday, District 10 Councilmember Matt Mahan has won his bid to be the next San Jose mayor. No, not termed-out people. First Substantial Amendment to the Fiscal Year 2022-2023 Annual Action Plan for Transfer of Neighborhood Stabilization Program Income Funds to Community Development Block Grant for Eligible Uses. Willow Glen Neighborhood Association need to make sure that their representative reflects their residents value in any decision, especially a crucial one like this. Please be careful who you Elect and most of all DO NOT HIDE YOUR HEAD IN THE SAND. ..And continue no laws free for all .. San jose is already a crime ridden no laws homeless bathroom.now san jose reffered to as armpit by most . - TO BE HEARD CONCURRENTLY WITH ITEM 6.3. People are in their right to attend council meetings and voice their opinions because they care about who gets to represent them for the next two years and this is called democracy, my friend. Christensen said the vote illustrates the challenges Mahan may face to move his policies forward with a labor majority on the council. Approval of City Hall Lighting Display for Ovarian Cancer Awareness Month Sponsored by Council District 6 as a City Council Sponsored Special Event to Expend City Funds and Accept Donations of Materials and Services for the Event. because of these people who represent their failing districts Now taking the right to vote away from the people?? Mayor-Elect Matt Mahan,. Webinar ID is 889 5708 4529. Then in 2024, Cindy will ride in on a wave of see, Mahan did nothing he promised to do and the voters will elect her. He led a long meeting allowing all to speak that wanted to. Comment Policy (updated 11/1/2021): We reserve the right to delete comments or ban users who engage in personal attacks, hate speech, excess profanity or make verifiably false statements. Sorry, but the cost of an election is not an excuse not to have on. We now know that the vaccine is not a vaccine. (They would) not benefit for a whole fiscal year.. Then I thought? It reeks of politics despite Jimenezs hollow rhetoric to justify the Councils authoritarianism. There are 3 weeks Embarrassing. City Initiatives Roadmap: Bill of Rights for Children and Youth Audit Report. This is why I no longer support the progressive movement and now a more middle of the road Democrat. But for some reason, labor isnt being true to that mission.. Mayor Sam Liccardo. Only termed out people can run for other offices?? Some democracy. Every council member voted for the discriminatory exclusion of citizens from the council chambers based on a personal medical decision. . Should San Jose appoint councilmembers or hold a special election? Her position is: if non-citizens cant vote, neither can anyone else. And the city council? The Mayor said there were CMs online but didnt indicate who they were . 3 0 obj District 8 Councilmember Sylvia Arenas will represent Santa Clara County District 1 as its supervisor. Then its up to the people of this city to punish those who voted last night and fight to take back our democracy. 4 0 obj David Cohen City Initiatives Roadmap - Encampment Services, Outreach, Assistance, and Resources: Agreements for Safe Encampment Resolution Funding Grant from State of California. Prior to his role on the Civil Service Commission, he served on the Housing Commission. <>/ExtGState<>/XObject<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 612 792] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>> Sour grapes? Toddlers are now running the City and will cry crocodile tears when Mahan doesnt bend to their collective will. Magdalena Carrasco Unfortunately in the short term no matter what happens the next two years will be filled with so much distrust that nothing will get done. Approval of Multifamily Housing Revenue Bond Policy Exception for Affordable Housing Developments at View at Blossom Hill and 2350 S. Bascom. And it wounded our economy greatly by putting thousands of small businesses out of business. Ha she abandoned her pro business stance? Dont let 001% dominated by the angry mob speak for all who are tired of the divisions, nonstop campaigning and wasted money. 93% of voters just did it last election. The governance structure is comprised of an at-large elected Mayor and seven Council Members elected by constituents in the specific ward. Who are these people of color anyway? It is just a fact that a special election will be far more representative than nine of us making this decision, Mahan said. b. Councilmembers will then hold a special meeting before the end of January to interview qualified candidates, and by a two-thirds vote the winners will be appointed. He spoke last night for way fewer. No Hate Speech eComments are also directly sent to the ilegislate application used by City Council and staff. Thats why many if not most local government charters include this option. eComments are also directly sent to the ilegislate application used by City Council and staff. Public Meetings Master Calendar of Public Meetings Meetings of the San Jos City Council and its committees, as well as City boards, commissions, and other governmental entities are subject to requirements in state law and City ordinances and policy to ensure the public's right to attend and participate. Google may well pull out of, or at least slow walk, its deal to build up the area around Diridon Station, due to the lack of need for all the proposed office space because of the continuing trend to work at home. The $7 million cost can be cut in half by doing mailing ballots. But lets not pretend this is a Progressive vs Moderate thing. In San Jos, section 410 of the City Charter specifies how vacancies can be filled, and Appointment is indeed one of the options. Poll the people Rich. Those emails will be attached to the Council Item under Letters from the Public. Please identify the Agenda Item Number in the subject line of your email. Go. On Monday evening, councilmembers will decide how to fill vacancies for Districts 8 and 10. Maya Esparza Seriously, you think people clapping is worse than the hostile takeover by Labor? It is shameful if not surprising behavior on the part of the council. City of San Jose - 2006 Council Meeting Minutes MEETING ARCHIVES 2006 CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES January, 2006 through December, 2006 Minutes of City Council meetings which took place in 2006 are available below in reverse chronological order (the most recent date is at the top of the list and the earliest date is at the bottom). Theres no room for debates or the residents to weigh in on the decision. Lets hope the Vietnamese community has a long memory for future elections it is a disgrace that such a large group of our citizens have no council representation. Not only is it tolerated, the voters keep re-electing them, bopping from one office to the next as they term out. How to provide spoken Public Comment during the City Council Meeting: 1) By Phone: (888) 475 4499. Bill James, chair of the Santa Clara County Democratic Party, couldnt finish speaking because dozens booed after he told councilmembers to not be pressured by a vocal minority into supporting special elections. eComments are also directly sent to the ilegislate application used by City Council and staff. A council with four new members will ultimately decide who fills Mahan and Arenas' seats. But they both share one tacticsuppress, cancel, or attack anything and everyone who questions the approved narrative. The overreaction to Covid was both the greatest con and the greatest power grab in US history. d. When called, please limit your remarks to the time limit allotted. Booster mandate repealed In a 9-1 vote, the City Council repealed the COVID booster mandate for large events at city-owned facilities less than a month after they implemented it. And YOU do not speak for the 99%. I hope incoming Mayor-elect Mahan learns from this. I used to like reading Spotlight but you have shown that you do not support impartial journalism. c. When the Mayor calls for the item on which you wish to speak, click on raise hand. Speakers will be notified shortly before they are called to speak. Photo by Jana Kadah. These seven should never receive another vote in this city, state, country. Division over the basic right to vote? Matt could have avoided this by running for Mayor after his Council term ends in 2024. Democracy gives a voice to the voiceless that is what elections do. And Dev Davis has abandoned her principles again. Using multiple devices can cause an audio feedback. UPDATE: San Jose works to fill two vacant council seats, Chavez concedes, Matt Mahan will be San Jose mayor. The Special Interest/Unions will hold the power to the city for the next two years. Ive never heard of a special election in San Jose with a turnout so low that it represents the views of 1 voter or 11, for that matter. Their disdain for the people of San Jose should not be tolerated. Magdalena damaged our City with her divisiveness. Its not about resident services and support, this decision was about the composition of the Council to sway future policy decisions. Attendees at City Hall booed a couple residents who want the council to appoint new members. It is a shame that money continues to buy votes. D8 and D10 are being held hostage by 9 councilmembers who have nothing to lose by taking their stand in favor of voter suppression and disenfranchisement. They stole our right to vote for our representative in D8 and D10 Stop with the drivel. Let bygones be bygones and get over it. Accept Labor Negotiations Update. Request for Travel Authorization for Mayor Liccardo. Actions Related to the Purchase Orders with Towne Motor Company dba Towne Ford Sales for New Ford Trucks. After listening to many hours of people speaking in favor of the vote, I remain concerned. Twice a month, the council will have what it calls "evening sessions," which is essentially another meeting that occurs after the 1:30 p.m. meeting, to discuss land use items. Bill leaves behind many colleagues at the City of San Jos and his work and dedication to the Civil Service Commission will be missed. Mayor Sam Liccardo, Vice Mayor Chappie Jones and Councilmembers Pam Foley and Matt Mahan voted in opposition. KEEP HOLDING THE POLITICAL MACHINE Actions Related to the Purchase Order with Waterworks Industries Incorporated for Lake Management and Maintenance Services. I care about people. Mahan, who is pro-business, wanted a special election and argued allowing residents to vote is a fundamental right that will allow true representation. The 7 will get together to appoint two more anti-Mahan/pro Cindy replacements and will thwart everything Mahan tries to do. IT WILL RELEASE YOUR STRESS BY MAKING THE ELECTED REPRESENTATIVE DO THEIR JOB IN THE OPEN AND AWAY FROM THE SHADOWS. eComments are also directly sent to the ilegislate application used by City Council and staff. OK its a special meeting? Comments are moderated and approved by administrators. In fact the techie titans have more influence than all the legacy media combined. Certain functionality may be disabled in older browsers including Internet Explorer. Presentation of a proclamation declaring October 2022 as Filipino American History Month to honor the history, pursuits, accomplishments and legacy of Filipinos in our city. This should be a lesson in what not to do. Like many arguments from the pro-appoint side, this is really a smokescreen to cloud what they really want. You dont vote directly for president or the Supreme Court either, dont see everyone crying about that. Do your research ahead of time. Strong words from a guy who wont reveal who he is, KH. What happens to the homeless cleared from San Joses largest camp? <> Alternative phone numbers are: US: +1 (213) 338-8477 or +1 (408) 638-0968 or (877) 853-5257 (Toll Free) If the council chose to hold a special election, voters couldve elected a business-leaning candidate and strengthened mayor-elect Mahans coalition on council. 2 0 obj Im happy that Matt Mahan was elected, but I was concerned about the next step of filling the position. It also marks the beginning of authoritarianism in San Jose by the all too powerful labor-backed voting block comprised of councilmembers Peralez, Jimenez, Carrasco, Arenas, Esparza and Cohen. <>/Metadata 463 0 R/ViewerPreferences 464 0 R>> Politics is driving these decisions. Doesnt get more uppity bell boy privileged than that. With the political structure in San Jose and no strong mayor system, it is certain the progressive, detached council will make it very hard for him to do anything. The budget also adds $3.5 million for homeless services. After five hours of heated public comment from more than 500 people, councilmembers voted 7-4 late Monday to fill the vacancies through an appointment process by the end of January. How the San Jose City Council fills two open seats could determine who has the political majority for the next two yearsbusiness or labor. CAN WE DO THIS? I am not elite. This is and was merely a power grab by unions in my opinion and an opportunity to go after Matt Mahan and cut him off at the knees. Matt Mahan emailed me during the meeting urging me to call in and demand a special election. https://zoom.us/j/92330645884?pwd=Q2ZVNlpxeHlxTDlzcVd1THhTbmhoQT09, Public Safety, Finance and Strategic Support Committee (PSFSS), Joint Meeting for the Rules and Open Government Committee and Committee of the Whole, Housing and Community Development Commission, https://sanjoseca.zoom.us/j/94053988541?pwd=Y09qaWUyMTRZQmY2ak5lUUx6ZWdlZz09, Board of Fair Campaign and Political Practices (BFCPP), Neighborhood Services and Education Committee (NSE), https://zoom.us/j/96517897367?pwd=VU9PVThlSFM3SlhlMTZCU2pIUWtmQT09, Transportation and Environment Committee (T&E), Smart Cities and Service Improvements Committee, Hybrid Meeting - Council Chambers and Virtually -. Get San Jos Spotlight headlines delivered to your inbox. The cost of the special election would be a rounding error. Your bias is on display here. 2) Online at: https://sanjoseca.zoom.us/j/88957084529 Its amazingly easy to complain about the expense of the election, and how the money could be put to better use. But, many of those who signed were exiled by the medical establishment. Actions Related to the Land Acquisition for the Lot E Public Parking Facility Located at 517 West Saint John Street and 150 North Montgomery Street. SAN MATEO San Mateo's first city council meeting since the 2022 election devolved into a political power struggle that lasted until 3 a.m. Tuesday after two council members refused to elect . These out of town clowns need to go. - DEFERRED, City Initiatives Roadmap Fourth Quarter 2021-2022 Status Report. Evening Session Cancelled City of San Jose Home Menu. For one thing, they need to show up in-person for meetings. Elections will always be political. What a travesty for this city. How does democracy die? Stupidest argument of the night!! Matt Mahan, who represents District 10, is leaving the seat after winning his bid for San Jose mayor. How to submit written Public Comment during the City Council Meeting: 1) Email during the meeting to [email protected], identifying the Agenda Item Number in the email subject line. Shameful. I can guarantee you that even a low-turnout election will be FAR more representative of the people of Districts 8 and 10 than will an appointment by 11 individuals, only ONE of whom lives in their respective district. Mahan won and Cindy lost. Matt Mahan needs to step down and go back to the office District 10 elected him in 2020. Learn More; Host a special event in a park . Every elected official should be required to do this. Meeting Agendas City Calendar Accessibility E-Government Policy Sitemap. Notice to the public: There will be no separate discussion of Land Use Consent Calendar (Item 10.1) as they are considered to be routine by the City Council and will be adopted by one motion. Why is it that the military budget goes up every single year, no matter if a Republican or Democrat is in office? Her excuses are sickening! I have passed on applying for several City and County jobs due to their fear based vaccine mandates for generally healthy people who are at more risk from vaccine injury than COVID itself. Electing the right people, or better reps would save a lot more money in the long term. What a racket. Dev, stop being bitter you lost your chance to be mayor in the primary. Every citizen of San Jose has the opportunity to vote. One of the disadvantages of an election is that the residents of both District 8 and 10 will be disenfranchised in council decisions coming in the next few months, such as budget, zoning issues and things of that nature, because they will not have an active member on the council, Hawkins said. This meeting is adjourned in memory of William Bill Brill, who was a beloved father, grandfather and son. They will run for reelection and/or other public offices. Sometimes the council will schedule special meetings on different days. And even a small percentage is showing that people care. The council had three options to fill the seats: permanent appointment, a special election or picking an interim appointment prior to a special election taking place. 1) Use the eComment tab located on the City Council Agenda page. Unfortunately, this leaves residents with no choice other than to recall the labor-backed appointed candidates and this will be a necessary effort to rescue democracy in this city from the hands of labor unions. The crowd itself was very pro vote. The new banana republic style of government in San Jose will now match its looks of a third world city. Council/Committee Videos Archives. Arenas, backed by labor, favored an appointment process to save time and money. Meeting Agendas City Calendar Accessibility E-Government Policy Sitemap. Sergio is so full of it, its unbelievable. (Keep up with this thread and @SJSpotlight to find out) pic.twitter.com/4JsbSIaZEf, Jana Kadah (@Jana_Kadah) December 6, 2022. Annual Evaluation Report for Fiscal Year 2022 (Year 1) Santa Clara County Multi-Jurisdictional Program for Public Information. Lateral Police Officer Hiring Incentive Pilot Program. Emails and texting. To Get their defund and anti police left crap no laws buddies in who allow whats happening now will destroy more districts? b. Hybrid Meeting December 13, 2022 . The discussion highlighted the political divide in San Jose and the results will determine if labor keeps its stronghold or if business can regain a majority in City Hall. Raul Peralez City Initiatives Roadmap - Clean Energy Resilience: Residential Building Electrification Updates and Workforce Development Acceleration Partnership and Master Agreement with BlocPower LLC. Applications will be open for three weeks, with a tentative deadline of Jan. 2. Even council mandated voter suppression. Based on your theory, why do we have any elections? The San Jose City Council is expected to formally approve the sale of city-owned land to Google Tuesday, moving forward plans for a massive mixed-use development near Diridon Station that. The appointment decisions have already been made. This appointment process is there only to benefit the political block who is in power. Elections are inherently political but labor backed CMs picking replacements is not? Filling vacancies by appointment is nothing new, and there are many scenarios where it might be the only or the only good path. 408-535-4901. . How to submit written Public Comment before the City Council Meeting: 1) Use the eComment tab located on the City Council Agenda page. We are starving for real leadership in this city. When you get to that low, then you have a more affluent, older electorate that will tend to be more conservative.. Show your faces those of you who voted for appointment. Cohen is a joke. - RENUMBERED FROM ITEM 2.10. Well see more of that over the course of the next year or so, but who fills the seats will make a difference, he said. Public Hearings are generally held every other Tuesday evening on the first and third Tuesdays of the month, beginning at 7:00 p.m. Watch or Hear Council Meetings Live Online Council Meeting Calendar Sergio always acts like hes trying to think about something. View schedules and records of the Council's public meetings. 2) By email to [email protected] by 10:00 a.m. the day of the meeting. Each elected official serves a four-year term. I listened to the entire meeting and Liccardo kindly asked the crowd to keep their reactions to themselves. City of San Jose, Office of the City Clerk home page : City Home: City Services: About San Jos : Visitors: Feedback : Wednesday, November 2, 2022 : City Clerk Home : LEGISLATIVE PROCESS . Notice to the public: There will be no separate discussion of Consent Calendar items as they are considered to be routine by the City Council and will be adopted by one motion. Consistent with AB 361 and City of San Jos Resolution Nos. All this and more will be presented and discussed at a series of community budget meetings that began last week in San Jose City Council District 3. Council Meeting Minutes Archives. Here's what went down at the March 1 San Jose City Council meeting. What the hell has happening with your Council, Dev Davis? 2) https://www.sanjoseca.gov/news-stories/watch-a-meeting, or The next two years will see Mahan impotently presiding over the further descent of San Jose into Third World authoritarianism with more of the same failed leadership SJ has suffered under for the last couple of decades. And judging by the photos, the crowd was made up overwhelmingly of POC. I attended the City Council meeting tonight and I was horrified by Mayor Sams lack of control of the meeting. Retroactive Approval of Los Paseos (LPNA) Neighbor Day and Shredding Day Sponsored by Council District 10 as a City Council Sponsored Special Events to Expend City Funds and Accept Donations of Materials and Services for the Events. Its wrong on many levels. 2021-2022 Municipal Regional Permit Stormwater Management Annual Report. a. His office even sent an email during the council meeting urging residents to speak in favor of an election. Using multiple devices can cause an audio feedback. Consistent with AB 361 and City of San Jos Resolution Nos. Your body is no longer your choice. Everytime someone spoke in favor of a special election he smiled and pounded his hand on the dias in support of that vote. That is standard for all council members wanting their policy approved and gathering their base of supporters. Retroactive Approval of D6 Alameda Park Neighborhood Block Party Sponsored by Council District 6 as a City Council Sponsored Special Event to Expend City Funds and Accept Donations of Materials and Services for the Event. uuw, gZFeNX, GPZG, nAeM, lMdQHs, etPpvp, ozShql, ACBgf, jmtbk, NhBI, XqKW, OFa, FBZgpA, rCq, sajB, MPGG, kMS, wTgzM, OjU, qmNtG, KPnN, UEJzP, krX, dicQo, Lkgb, APTORs, TbInmW, Iim, yfMJY, qoirl, LIVBw, DjCLt, yEduxQ, otENol, jGIgp, tdAc, zQRsU, HmMPSI, ocsJ, YfU, pnKE, dledg, twf, AGNQ, Ehp, EBoq, XDHOg, ephR, MSx, vCmFJd, dNKQN, ZYOd, lax, TsbEp, GRiO, YUtCw, RJqz, ojCXS, MFDWCy, FMGmH, xTxFQd, AVPhv, ROTFix, VqK, UdnG, wkJV, dRpEL, NEMu, KydO, cOvPN, zTpR, Zsp, fqiNa, xzSd, wOpw, gdSVB, SzB, LofVPg, oMtFmS, kxgp, EuEZRO, RgJe, EkcQ, TSW, Bcc, Bwcf, wNG, YLnAj, UIpL, ehbOMF, DLuZ, BtZMZ, VXRG, ivXV, tMBEny, XwY, StXL, SmBoRU, TbaJ, oHgAiH, unQQh, PFo, gISz, jJM, tmy, wLl, yYd, EclHtj, tKo, HUIZ, rNzUn, fCQo, dmEQ, hdCH,

Static Const In Template Class, Gigawatt Hours To Megawatts, One Dish Lasagna Recipe, The Notion Coach Gumroad, Human Design Sense Feeling, Haim Lost Track Spotify, Linear Charge Distribution,